This is an archival discussion recap:
We had one of those discussion about The Wailing Wind, by Tony Hillerman, where some enjoyed the book and others didn't but everyone enjoyed the discussion! I didn't like the book, but while I was reading it, I was wondering what the discussion would bring, and that made me finish the book. And, at the discussion, I was glad I finished it! Actually, though the book was a mystery, I don't think our discussion even gave away the ending. So those who were there and didn't finish the book can still read it and maybe enjoy it all the more because of the discussion!